Showing posts with label tourism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label tourism. Show all posts

Wednesday, December 23, 2015

Write your way out

When I was in New York a few weeks ago, I saw Hamilton (the Musical). Although I bought the tickets months ago, I made it a point not to listen to it before I actually saw it in person. I'm not sure why - it wasn't exactly about "spoilers," because, well, I know what happens in that story. I think it was more wanting to try to see it without all the hype pushing in and, for the most part, I think it was a good decision. I enjoyed the show - it's smart, and impressive, and tear-jerking, and thought-provoking, and brave, and a little bit weird.

But, I think I'd like to see it again, somewhere in the distant future, when it feels less like an event and more like something I can relax and enjoy. For one thing, the audience seemed to be older and wealthier than most other shows I have seen. My impression is that Broadway audiences tend to skew a bit older in general, I imagine because of cost, distance, and other issues involving access. Given the intense popularity of Hamilton, all of these issues seemed to be exacerbated and the audience was definitely older, and whiter, than a lot of other shows I have seen. Those things aren't necessarily a problem, but they are particularly noticeably with a show like Hamilton, that itself is so diverse, and young, and "scrappy."It made it feel more like a see and be seen kind of thing, rather than an experience with an audience that was really loving it.

Also, it was hard to enjoy it outside the hype, despite my efforts to the contrary. I'd waited so long, and heard so much, and I was just trying to soak it in and experience it all. That type of pressure makes it difficult to be transported by the performances, no matter how great they were,  The immediacy, the music, the small audiences, the intense emotions - all of that is often conducive to the kind of rapture I want from musical theater. And some moments in Hamilton got me there, most noticeably in the songs from the Schuyler sisters. and in the whole Unimaginable sequence. Overall, the second half affected me a lot more than the first, though again, the whole thing is very impressive. I think it just got me more on a cerebral level, which I enjoyed, but which didn't transport me the way it has many other people.

That said, I've been listened to the music the last couple of days, now that it is available through Amazon Prime, which has only confirmed my initial impression that it is the most textual musical I can think of, especially in that second half. There are numerous references to both the prodigious amount of writing that Hamilton produced (the Federalist papers, the Reynolds pamphlet, his work as Secretary of the Treasury), Hamilton's compulsive need to write "as if he is running out of time," and Hamilton's fixation on his own legacy. As he puts it,

    I wrote my way out of hell
    I wrote my way to revolution
    I was louder than the crack in the bell
    I wrote Eliza love letters until she fell
    I wrote about the Constitution and defended it well
    And in the face of ignorance and resistance
    I wrote financial systems into existence
    And when my prayers to God were met with indifference
    I picked up a pen, I wrote my own deliverance

Here, writing is both public and private, something that defines Hamilton in all the spheres of his life. In fact, the above song "Hurricane" is prompted by Hamilton's own impending personal scandal. His response? "I'll write my way out."

Most interesting to me, however, is his wife's response to this Reynolds Pamphlet. Eliza sings "Burn," where she too acknowledges both the seduction of writing -

    You and your words flooded my senses
    Your sentences left me defenseless
    You built me palaces out of paragraphs
    You built cathedrals

And it's potential for betrayal -

    You published the letters she wrote you
    You told the whole world how you brought
    This girl into out bed

Eliza's response? In contrast to her earlier plea "to be part of the narrative," she now refuses not only Hamilton, but future historians, access to her body, her feelings, her thoughts, by refusing them access to her own writing:

   I'm erasing myself from the narrative
   Let future historians wonder how Eliza
   Reacted when you broke her heart

She burns Hamilton's letters as a response to both his desire for a legacy and the present's prurient desire to know the most intimate details of the lives of public figures. In other words, she refuses writing, or more precisely, refuses to be written (even, of course, as we are enthralled by Miranda's writing here and throughout the musical).

What really got to me, however, was when writing went from something to be refused to something inadequate (even, again, as that inadequacy is evoked through song) in "It's Quiet Uptown." As that song starts,

   There are moments that the words don't reach
   There is suffering too terrible to name

And from there, concluding with the female survivors taking the reins of the narrative in which masculinity generally dominates the story. There, at the end, Eliza and Angelica write the story of Hamilton - here, Eliza says that she put herself "Back in the narrative" - even as the refrain of "who lives, who dies, who tells your story" echoes. It's an interesting irony, because even though the dominant theme seems to be asking us to think about who tells the story, the song itself starts off with reminding us that we have "no control" over that story-telling. So, we might wonder who tells "our story," but really, that narrative is beyond us; we'll all be written by someone else, regardless of whether, like Hamilton, we are writing like we're running out of time.

Saturday, July 25, 2015

The Islands

So, I am sitting in my hotel room in Honolulu. The windows are shut, air con on. I am wearing a hotel robe, munching on dried seaweed, responding to portfolios. My luggage is back on Kona, though I am on Oahu. My driver's license is back at the Macy's in Sherman Oaks, though I fortunately had my passport. My credit card is also at that Macy's, but that's okay, because a few days earlier, someone in Canada stole it and began their lifelong dream of committing fraud to shop at Wal-Mart and McDonald's. Oh, and my luggage is on Kona because the plane taking me from LA to Honolulu blew an engine in the middle of the ocean and so had to chug it's way to the nearest stop (sorry, Kona!).

It's been a day.

But it's my first time in Hawaii. As I like to tell friends/family/random people, it's one of the five states I have left to visit. It's also a state that has moved across my imagination from time to time in various and oddly juxtaposed ways: most of my immediate family has been here (without me), which is a bit of a twist; the fourth chapter of my dissertation focuses on a text (Juliana Spahr's The The Transformation) that is partially set here; Dog the Bounty Hunter took place here. I'm not even joking about that last one - what shows like Dog and Storage Wars and Parking Wars all have in common (for me) is that they show how the "reality" of a place is far more than it's postcard promise. It's the same pleasure I get from crime novels: these are what the streets actually look like, these are how the people actually live, this is what it means to actually survive. All kinds of texts give us that "actually," but not all occur on places that are seemingly so at odds with the mundanity presented. Storage Wars in California is interesting, but in Texas, not so much. And Dog the Bounty Hunter fell flat when he went on the hunt in Colorado, but in Hawaii, I was intrigued.

So, now that I am in Hawaii, I have that so-called realism echoing around the back of my head (the meth, the repeat drug offenses, the glimpse of indigenous people living and working and navigating the complex colonial history of Hawaii as it plays out in tourism and drugs and poverty) combined with Spahr's own haole anxieties about academia's (and language's) colonizing force combined with my family's simple, nostalgic love for what truly is a beautiful, foreign and familiar place (and which, of course, is not without its own colonizing effect).

In her essay "In the Islands" from her collection The White Album, Joan Didion talks about coming to Hawaii with her husband in lieu of getting divorced. They stay at The Royal Hawaiian and she looks at the other rich people (the people "like her") feeling disconnected from them and herself. She then gives an account of the hotels history before moving onto a discussion of a cemetery for the dead from first WWII and then Vietnam. The essay, though, is really about how people own places through language, how certain places are forever associated with the writer who gave them life (she lists Hemingway, and Faulkner, and, in reference to Hawaii, James Jones).

I think she's right, in her way, because many of us do associate places with writings about them. One of my favorite habits is to read a crime novel in the place I am visiting. I like the kind of ownership those books display about a local place and that I can then vicariously feel. But I also think Didion's "being right" is also what makes Spahr and even Dog (the show) "right" - Hawaii is a place taken over (for me and for, I would imagine, most of its visitors) by all the forces that have permeated it over the last century, so much so that the only reference to native Hawaiians I encountered today was in the numerous complaints people made about the difficulty in pronouncing the street names.

Sunday, August 10, 2014

A Strange Land

Over the last few years, on my trips home over the Christmas holidays, my nephew and I have started taking trips to Oklahoma state parks. The main point is to travel with the nephew, because, well, it's fun, but the secondary goal is to experience the area in ways I haven't. Growing up, it was easy to think of this area as a land without history and without interest. The first assumption is obviously false, fraught with political and racist underpinnings; the second is just lazy. So, I've slowly started moving around, looking for things that are interesting, different, or unusual.

Last week (at my aunt's behest), I attended Marian Days in Carthage, MO, a city of around 14,000 that lies 130 miles NE from Tulsa. Marian Days is, according to my mostly Wikipedia-type sources, either the largest religious pilgrimage and festival in North America or simply the largest Roman Catholic festival in the United States. Either way, it's big. Over the first weekend in August, it brings over 50,000 Vietnamese American Roman Catholics to Carthage to honor the Virgin Mary and to reunite people from around the country, many of whom have been making the pilgrimage since 1978.


The festivities, which began as a one day retreat, take place on the 28-acre campus of the Congregation of the Mother Co-Redemptrix, land that used to house Our Lady of the Ozarks College but which was purchased in 1975 by an order of Vietnamese priests and nuns "who came to this country after fleeing Vietnam in fishing boats at the insistence of their founder, a day before South Vietnam fell to the Communists in 1975."


Following the fall of Saigon, thousands of Vietnamese refugees ended up at Fort Chaffee in Western Arkansas, including the 170 priests and brothers of the Congregation of the Mother Co-Redemptrix who were split between Fort Chaffee and Camp Pendleton in California. Over the next few years, people ended up all across the region, including tens of thousands of people who were relocated to Oklahoma City; Cardinal Bernard Law, then Bishop of Springfield – Cape Girardeau, sponsored all 170 members of the Congregation, allowing them use of a college in his diocese that had been closed for years. That group evolved into the congregation that still worships there today. 

And, for these few days every year, this small area becomes an orderly tent city, housing people in individual tents, large group tents with rows of cots, camper-trailers, and all the city's hotels.


I have to admit, I'm not sure about attending a religious celebration for a faith that I don't follow. I did feel weird at first, wandering through the temporary lanes that wound around the campus. But, while the festival is centered around liturgy, there are also a number of other events that are more open to the general public, such as the county-fair-like atmosphere of the adjacent food/drink/cotton candy area.








And so, I ate.

A lot.


And I walked around.

And I marveled at how much has gone on around me without me paying much attention. And it's not for lack of mention - my grandfather used to tell me about the thousands of people flooding into small-town Missouri, but I dismissed his stories as exaggeration tinged with xenophobia. It just sounded like paranoia and, besides, how big could something in Carthage be? Well, I was wrong, about Carthage, and my grandfather, and my own sense of worldliness that convinced me that nothing that interesting could be happening nearby without my travel-experienced mind paying heed.